Key takeaways
- Mine fatalities rose to 44 between January and August 2026, against 32 in the same period of 2025, and the Mine Health and Safety Amendment Bill is before Parliament.
- A section 54 instruction must be obeyed while it stands. An appeal to the Chief Inspector of Mines must be lodged within 30 days and does not suspend the instruction.
- The courts require an objective basis for an instruction, and have intervened where an instruction went well beyond the hazard identified.
Mine safety is once again under the spotlight. Recent reporting records 44 fatalities on South African mines between January and August 2026, compared with 32 in the same period of 2025, an increase of 37.5%. By August, the 2026 toll already exceeded the 41 deaths recorded in the whole of 2025, which had been the lowest annual figure on record. At the same time, the Mine Health and Safety Amendment Bill (B10-2026) (the Bill) is before Parliament, proposing heavier penalties and stronger executive accountability.
Against that background, mines and contractors should expect the inspectorate to make full use of its most disruptive enforcement tool: the instruction under section 54 of the Mine Health and Safety Act 29 of 1996 (MHSA). A section 54 instruction can halt all or part of a mine at short notice, and every hour of a stoppage carries a cost. How a mine responds in the first 24 hours often determines how quickly, and on what terms, operations resume.
The Power In Section 54
Section 54(1) of the MHSA provides that, if an inspector has reason to believe that any occurrence, practice or condition at a mine endangers or may endanger the health or safety of any person at the mine, the inspector may give any instruction necessary to protect the health or safety of persons at the mine. The instruction may include –
- that operations at the mine, or a part of the mine, be halted;
- that an act or practice be suspended or halted, or performed only subject to conditions;
- that the manager take specified steps, within a specified period, to rectify the occurrence, practice or condition; and
- that affected persons, other than those needed to rectify the condition, be moved to safety.
The power is broad, but it is not unlimited. The courts have held that the phrase “reason to believe” requires an objective basis: there must be facts that would lead a reasonable person to believe that health or safety is, or may be, endangered. An inspector’s subjective concern, however sincerely held, is not enough. The instruction must also be one that is “necessary” to protect persons at the mine, which brings proportionality into play.
Procedural Requirements
The MHSA prescribes how an instruction is to be given. In summary –
- the instruction is directed to the manager, a person designated by the manager or, where neither is available, the most senior employee available at the mine;
- an instruction given orally must be confirmed in writing and delivered as soon as possible, and the manager must receive a copy if it was given to someone else;
- an instruction to halt operations must be confirmed, varied or set aside by the Chief Inspector of Mines as soon as practicable; and
- before halting operations, the inspector must ordinarily give the manager and the employees’ representatives a reasonable opportunity to make representations, unless the delay involved would itself endanger health or safety.
These requirements matter in practice. A written instruction that is vague about the hazard, the affected area or the steps required is harder to comply with and easier to challenge. Where an inspector has relied on the urgency exception to dispense with representations, the mine is entitled to engage immediately afterwards, and should do so.
The First 24 Hours
The practical priorities on the day an instruction is issued are the following –
- Comply first – an instruction must be obeyed while it stands. Failing to comply with an inspector’s instruction is itself an offence, and a mine that continues to operate in breach of a halt exposes the company and its management to criminal liability;
- Secure the written instruction – obtain the written confirmation, and record precisely which areas, shafts, levels or practices are affected, the hazard identified and any steps or time periods specified;
- Gather the facts – assemble the evidence relevant to the condition identified, including inspection records, risk assessments, codes of practice, maintenance logs and photographs, while they are fresh;
- Engage with the inspector – representations and a credible remedial plan are often the quickest route to having a halt lifted or narrowed. Where the instruction applies more widely than the hazard requires, the representations should say so, with evidence;
- Involve the right people – the health and safety committee and employee representatives have statutory roles, and their participation strengthens the mine’s position; and
- Diarise the deadlines – the time for an appeal begins to run from the date of the decision, and urgent relief, if needed, must be pursued without delay.
Appeal Routes And Urgent Relief
Any person adversely affected by a decision of an inspector may appeal to the Chief Inspector of Mines under section 57 of the MHSA. The appeal must be lodged within 30 days of the decision and must set out the grounds of appeal. The Chief Inspector may confirm, set aside or vary the decision, or substitute another decision. A decision of the Chief Inspector may in turn be appealed to the Labour Court under section 58.
Critically, section 59 provides that an appeal under sections 57, 57A or 58 does not suspend the decision appealed against. The instruction therefore remains binding while the appeal is pending. Where a stoppage is unjustified and the losses are severe, a mine may need to approach the Labour Court urgently for an order suspending the instruction until the appeal is determined.
Proportionality: Lessons From The Courts
Two judgments illustrate the limits of the power. In Bert’s Bricks (Pty) Ltd and Another v Inspector of Mines, North West Region and Others [2012] ZAGPPHC 11, decided on 9 February 2012, the High Court considered a section 54(1) instruction issued after damage was found to the tyre tread of a forklift. The court confirmed that “reason to believe” requires objective facts, and found that there were none showing that the damage endangered anyone’s health or safety.
In AngloGold Ashanti Limited v Mbonambi and Others (J 2459/16), decided on 4 November 2016, instructions prohibiting the use of explosives and underground tramming across an entire mine were issued in response to conditions confined to a single level, which accounted for roughly 2% of the workforce. The court held that the instructions were out of all proportion to the problems identified, that they should at most have been limited to the affected level, and suspended them pending the appeal.
The courts’ approach is consistent. An inspector may stop what is dangerous, but an instruction that reaches well beyond the hazard identified is open to challenge, and mines should test overbroad instructions promptly rather than absorb the cost.
What The Amendment Bill Would Change
The Bill, introduced by the Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources, would not alter the basic structure of section 54, but it would change the environment in which instructions are issued and enforced. Among other things, it would –
- transfer the function of confirming, varying or setting aside a halt instruction from the Chief Inspector of Mines to a Principal Inspector of Mines;
- require every employer to appoint a chief executive officer responsible for ensuring that the employer’s functions are properly performed;
- extend an inspector’s power to prohibit the functioning of a mine site following a death, serious injury or serious illness, or an occurrence that threatens health;
- allow a convicted employer to be fined up to 10% of its annual turnover; and
- substantially increase the maximum fines and periods of imprisonment for a range of offences.
The Bill remains subject to the parliamentary process and may change before it is enacted. Its direction is nevertheless clear: accountability for safety failures is moving firmly towards the top of the organisation.
How Bishop Fraser Attorneys Can Assist
A section 54 instruction requires an immediate and measured response, combining legal, technical and operational input under severe time pressure.
Bishop Fraser Attorneys advises mines and contractors on responding to section 54 and section 55 instructions on the day they are issued, preparing representations and remedial plans, appeals to the Chief Inspector of Mines and the Labour Court, urgent applications to suspend instructions, accident inquiries and investigations, administrative fines and compliance with the MHSA more broadly. Early legal engagement, ideally before an incident arises, is almost always the more effective and less costly course.
Frequently asked questions
Does an appeal suspend a section 54 instruction?
No. Section 59 of the MHSA provides that an appeal under sections 57, 57A or 58 does not suspend the decision. To stop an unjustified halt in the meantime, a mine must apply urgently to the Labour Court.
How long do I have to appeal a section 54 instruction?
30 days from the decision. The appeal goes to the Chief Inspector of Mines under section 57 and must set out the grounds. The Chief Inspector’s decision may in turn be appealed to the Labour Court under section 58.
Can an inspector halt an entire mine for a problem in one area?
Only if that is necessary to protect health or safety. In AngloGold Ashanti v Mbonambi, the Labour Court found mine-wide instructions issued for conditions on a single level to be out of all proportion, and suspended them pending the appeal.

